Being Signal Amidst the Noise

If you like this presentation – show it...

Slide 0

Rand Fishkin, Wizard of Moz | @randfish | rand@moz.com Being Signal Amidst the Noise

Slide 1

bit.ly/randsignal Get the presentation:

Slide 2

5 Minutes Online Online

Slide 3

Let’s see what’s going on…

Slide 4

Sounds fun, but no time Meh. Don’t need it. I know I should read this… Meh. Saw that earlier. Yeah, yeah. Not causation blah blah.

Slide 5

Meh. Maybe later. Meh. Thanks Richard! I should check these, but… Cool. Older post. I can probably skip.

Slide 6

At some point, I need to read through these… Ad. Ignore.

Slide 7

Why are there so many @#$%! kinds of notifications!? 283? I’m never going to have time for this…

Slide 8

Whoa. I should really comment on this, and maybe send my friends an email to say congrats.

Slide 9

@#$%! Assholes are trying to ruin the gender-balance progress we’ve been making as an industry. Whoa! Friends are having babies! I should really drop them a line…

Slide 10

Meh. Meh. Meh. Meh.

Slide 11

I might read this one… The rest of these… Meh.

Slide 12

This sounds interesting.

Slide 13

Ugh. Email’s overloaded again.

Slide 14

Actually, that only took me 4 Minutes 4 Minutes

Slide 15

More People Online Spending More Time Clicking More Stuff + + = Easier to Get Web Traffic!

Slide 16

More People Online Spending More Time Clicking More Stuff + + = Easier to Get Web Traffic! x Harder

Slide 17

The Law of Shitty Clickthrough Rates Via Andrew Chen’s Blog

Slide 18

Part of brain that pays attention Internet

Slide 19

Via Has Technology Changed Us Research into brain plasticity suggests that screen engagement is literally rewiring our minds

Slide 20

This Leaves Marketers in a Scary Predicament Why isn’t anyone paying attention to me?!

Slide 21

Stand out from the crowd

Slide 22

Or Become the Noise Everyone’s Trying to Filter Hello?

Slide 23

Strategies to Become Signal Amidst the Noise 5

Slide 24

Pursue Less Accessible Opportunities #1

Slide 25

Everyone is Chasing the Same Keywords

Slide 26

AdWords Hiding Data Spells Opportunity for Those Who Broaden their Keyword Sets

Slide 27

AdWords Hiding Data Spells Opportunity for Those Who Broaden their Keyword Sets Clearly, they have search volume…

Slide 28

UberSuggest & KeywordTool.io are Used by Many Folks

Slide 29

Google Suggest + Wildcards Are Rarely Used

Slide 30

Related Searches Are Also Underutilized

Slide 31

As is Google Correlate

Slide 32

Manually Extracting Topics, Interests, and Language from Online Discussions Is Hardest (and least pursued) of All

Slide 33

Top Influencers Attract Everyone’s Attention

Slide 34

But these folks have massively busy streams, often teeming with “outreach attempts”

Slide 35

Perhaps, we could look at who influences them…

Slide 36

Or sort our influencers by more useful metrics

Slide 37

Or scroll further down the list to find those who’d be more receptive

Slide 38

Marketers Are Told to Pursue Channels & Tactics that Scale

Slide 39

Via the GrooveHQ Blog Which means the tactics that don’t scale stand out from the crowd

Slide 40

A personal email from the CEO/founder to every single new customer?

Slide 41

This is not a man, but rather, a machine intelligence, simulating a human, sent to show us all what incredible participation on a social network looks like.

Slide 42

My non-scalable activity is to answer almost every request I get – to meet, to answer questions, to do an interview – doing that for a decade has built some hard-to-replicate goodwill connections.

Slide 43

Invest in Formats that Others Avoid #2

Slide 44

The Easier Content is to Create; The Harder it is to Stand Out

Slide 45

Blog Post Tweet Useful Guide Interactive Tool Guest Contribution for a Notable Publisher Photo Mobile App Video Custom Illustration Physical Product Successful, scalable community Easier Harder

Slide 46

The Fastest Growing Social Platforms Are Based on Visuals: Via Global Web Index

Slide 47

Visuals are often perceived as more trustworthy and accurate than text alone. Chart from NYMag’s Science of Us, Data from Prof. Brendan Nyhan

Slide 48

Unfortunately, A Lot of Marketing Investments in Visuals… Well… Suck.

Slide 49


Slide 50


Slide 51


Slide 52

If You Can Stand Out Amidst this Crowd, Amplification is Far Easier to Achieve Data from Stone Temple Consulting’s Dec. 2014 Twitter Engagement Study

Slide 53

Weirdly, Authentic & Amateur seems to often outperform Polished & Professional Via T-Shaped Web Marketer and Why SEOs Need to Care About Correlation

Slide 54

The Less Directly a Tactic Leads to Sales, the Less the Competition

Slide 55

Most Marketers and Sites Focus on Optimizing for Conversion Get More and More People Through These Steps And Get Paid $$

Slide 56

But Investments in Education and Entertainment are Often Less Crowded Overrun with ads; hypercompetitive No ads; plenty room for new players

Slide 57

Playing Games Browsing Social Reading News Engaging in Discussions Following Influencers If you get to know your audience well enough, you’ll know what they do before they ever reach the funnel

Slide 58

Research If You Don’t Know… Via Growing Your Audience w/ Random Affinities Via Use Customer Surveys to Define Your Content Marketing Efforts Ask

Slide 59

Adopt Early, While Competitors Delay #3

Slide 60

Facebook’s Ads Are Finally Reaching Saturation

Slide 61

But These Platforms Aren’t (Yet) Via Instagram Starts Letting Ads Be Clickable

Slide 62

See A Pinteresting New PPC Platform

Slide 63

Excellent article from AJ Kohn on using StumbleUpon + Remarketing with Great Results

Slide 64

See Native or Not, Gum Gum’s In-Image Ads Work, and That’s What Matters

Slide 65

See The Advertiser’s Guide to Surviving Reddit

Slide 66

Mobile-Friendly is Table Stakes, But Mobile-First is Still in Infancy

Slide 67

Via Benefits of a Mobile-First Design Strategy

Slide 68

Tinder is one of the most powerful examples of a mobile-first design success.

Slide 69

Via What Can We Learn from Tinder

Slide 70

CNN has recently been experimenting with mobile-first content formats that create unique, engaging experiences around content.

Slide 71

Target Keywords, Sites, & Influencers BEFORE they Become Popular

Slide 72

As an early Niice supporter, Mailchimp got a sweet ad deal to a great audience

Slide 73

Today’s news forms tomorrow’s keyword demand Via PopURLs

Slide 74

When stories like this becomes popular, keyword demand skyrockets, and fresher content has a better chance to rank.

Slide 75

Reaching Top Influencers Can Feel Almost Impossible

Slide 76

I may not be able to get Nilofer’s attention, but I can probably get in front of her up-and-coming influencers (via followeronk)

Slide 77

Socialbakers will show you the fastest-growing profiles on Twitter, G+, & Youtube in given categories and countries

Slide 78

Pay Attention to Correlation as Well as Causal Inputs #4

Slide 79

In Social Media, Correlation Data is Well-Accepted Via Stone Temple’s Study of 4M+ Tweets

Slide 80

e.g. Social Shares are Poorly Correlated w/ Content Engagement Via What You Think You Know About the Web Is Wrong (from Chartbeat)

Slide 81

e.g. Facebook Likes of Movie Pages Are Well-Correlated to Box Office Returns Via CitizenNet

Slide 82

Via Experience the Blog Little Correlation Between Facebook Activity and Stock Performance

Slide 83

We Use Correlation Data Intelligently in CRO Via Wordstream & KISS Metrics

Slide 84

And In Advertising Via Comscore & MarketingLand

Slide 85

But, For Some Reason, When We Observe Correlations in SEO…. Via SearchMetrics Google UK Correlations

Slide 86

Everyone Loses Their Minds

Slide 87

Via Northcutt Blog

Slide 88

When You Hear This: “Just because you implement schema.org doesn’t necessarily mean you should rank higher.” Via Does Use of Schema.org Markup Create a Ranking Benefit

Slide 89

Think This: “Schema might boost your rankings, because CTR, which is improved by schema, can directly or indirectly affects rankings.” Via Does Use of Schema.org Markup Create a Ranking Benefit

Slide 90

Then Consider Analyzing the Data: Via Schema Analysis in SERPs from SearchMetrics

Slide 91

Correlation doesn’t tell us why a site/page ranks higher than another.

Slide 92

Correlation tells us what features & metrics sites/pages that rank higher have that lower ranking sites/pages don’t have.. More in this post: Why SEOs Need to Care About Correlation

Slide 93

I want to know what top ranking sites are doing differently than lower ranking sites, even if it’s not a directly causal input to Google’s algorithm! More in this post: Why SEOs Need to Care About Correlation

Slide 94

Invest in the Hardest Tactic to Measure: Brand #5

Slide 95

Via Microsoft Research’s Domain Bias in Web Search Web Searchers Are Strongly Biased by Brands Searchers clicked WebMD 25%+ more often, even when it was given a less relevant snippet

Slide 96

Via Queries & Clicks Can Influence Google’s Results Given that Queries & Clicks Can Influence Rankings… A few hundred clicks moved this result from #7 to #1 in under 3 hours.

Slide 97

And that Topical Domain Authority is Such a Powerful Influencer of Rankings: Via Cognitive SEO’s Panda 4.0 Analysis

Slide 98

Via Forbes’ Top Brands List Brand May Be a Huge Asset

Slide 99

Via SEER Interactive’s Post on Offline Advertising Influencing Organic Search In the Future, Brand Advertising May Be a Part of How SEO Campaigns Are Done:

Slide 100

Rand Fishkin, Wizard of Moz | @randfish | rand@moz.com bit.ly/randsignal